world 6 min read

Sanctioning Judges Undermines International Law

The US threat to sanction Nobel laureate Navi Pillay over a potential Myanmar genocide ruling marks a dangerous escalation. It risks hollowing out the rule-of-law framework that underpins all international courts.

  • Human Rights
  • International Law
  • United States
  • Myanmar
  • International Court of Justice

A Warning Shot Heard Around The World

Mike Waltz did not mince words when addressing Navi Pillay directly last month. The US ambassador to the UN told the Nobel Peace Prize recipient that Washington “will not allow globalist, faux judges to weaponise the law against our troops.” He accused Pillay of trying to lower the legal threshold for proving genocide so that the standard could later be turned against American soldiers. This was not veiled diplomacy. It was a threat delivered in public, intended to influence the outcome of a case that has not yet been heard.

Pillay sits on the bench at the International Court of Justice as the ad hoc judge appointed by The Gambia, the state bringing the Myanmar genocide case concerning the Rohingya. She was selected precisely because she is an outsider to the regular membership — a move designed to inject perspective into proceedings where the court has never once found a state responsible for genocide. On Thursday, the ICJ is expected to deliver its judgment on whether Myanmar systematically targeted the Rohingya during military operations in Rakhine state in 2016 and 2017.

The foundation close to the White House has already predicted that sanctions will follow if the court issues a genocide finding. Several sources indicate preparations are underway within the US administration to target individual judges, with Pillay foremost among them.

What Happens When Judges Are Held Hostage

The United States has never faced credible consequences for ignoring international court orders in recent memory. In 2024, the ICJ issued provisional measures requiring Israel to admit more aid into Gaza and cooperate with Unrwa. Israel refused. There was no response from Washington commensurate with the gravity of the defiance. Now the same administration that tolerated those breaches is preparing to punish judges for the act of judging.

This reversal reveals something important about how power operates at the international level. The US treats the ICJ as a useful tool when its conclusions align with strategic interests and discards it entirely when they do not. Under Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Washington formally determined that Myanmar had committed genocide — a position it is now threatening to undermine by attacking the institution tasked with making that determination. Marco Rubio, Blinken’s successor, has gone further. Last week he declared that international law is merely an instrument used by a global elite to advance their interests under the pretence of universal principles, adding that the ICC should not quote laws to men with swords.

These statements come from the two most powerful figures in American foreign policy. They are not fringe commentary. They signal a deliberate doctrine.

The Ripple Effect No One Is Discussing

The immediate stakes concern Myanmar and the Rohingya. But the broader implications stretch far beyond South East Asia. If the ICJ establishes that genocide intent can be inferred from patterns of conduct — forced displacement, attacks on fleeing civilians, treatment of children, gender-based violence — then that reasoning becomes available in every future case. Israel faces exactly this legal architecture in proceedings brought by South Africa at The Hague. A lower threshold for proving genocide in the Myanmar case makes an adverse ruling against Israel more likely. That is precisely why the Trump administration sees a direct threat.

The court itself understands the danger. According to reports, judges have taken advice on protecting their personal assets from potential US sanctions. This is unprecedented. The ICJ has sat in The Hague since 1946. Its judges have faced hostility before, but never financial threats designed to chill specific outcomes in live proceedings.

Europeans are watching closely. The UK and five other states filed a joint submission arguing that intent should be assessed comprehensively, examining all relevant circumstances rather than requiring proof of systematic killing alone. Their argument reflects a sophisticated understanding of how genocide operates in practice — through displacement, starvation, destruction of community structures — not just mass execution. If the court adopts this approach, it strengthens the legal framework that protects vulnerable populations worldwide. If the court retreats under pressure, it sets back international human rights law by decades.

Why This Matters Beyond The Courtroom

The parallel with the ICC is instructive but incomplete. The United States imposed crippling sanctions on ICC judges after the court issued arrest warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu and other Israeli officials. Those sanctions targeted individuals who exercised criminal jurisdiction over alleged war crimes. The ICJ operates differently. It settles disputes between sovereign states. Its judgments do not produce prison sentences but they do produce legally binding determinations of state responsibility. When a state is found guilty of genocide, the obligations that flow from that finding are immense — including duties under the Genocide Convention to prevent and punish the crime.

Sanctioning ICJ judges sends a message that transcends any single case. It tells every authoritarian government that international courts are discretionary venues rather than compulsory ones. If the world’s most powerful state can threaten judges for delivering unwelcome verdicts, then every court from The Hague to Geneva loses credibility. Small states lose protection. Vulnerable populations lose their only recourse.

There is a narrow opening. The ICC recently dropped its inquiry into US soldiers and intelligence agents for alleged unlawful acts in Afghanistan, citing evidentiary difficulties. One side-effect may be reduced US enthusiasm for sanctions against the ICC as an institution. Washington may calculate that preserving some relationship with international justice mechanisms serves its long-term interests better than open confrontation. But that calculus does not apply to the ICJ, where the case is concrete, the political pressure is intense, and the stakes for the court’s institutional survival are existential.

What Comes Next

The judgment on Myanmar will arrive regardless of threats from Washington. The real question is whether the ICJ’s reasoning survives intact or shrinks under the weight of intimidation. A cautious opinion that avoids broadening the definition of genocide intent would reflect fear disguised as prudence. It would also embolden every government that has ever worried about being held accountable for atrocities.

Navi Pillay spent her career advocating for victims of sexual violence in conflict and building legal frameworks to prosecute impunity. Her appointment to this case was meant to bring exactly that experience to a court that has never penalized a state for genocide. The fact that her participation has become a target reveals how deeply the current US administration views independent adjudication as an adversary rather than a pillar of the order it claims to support.

The sanctions will likely fall. The damage to the court’s authority will outlast them. Once judges are financially exposed for ruling against powerful states, the illusion of impartiality cracks permanently. No amount of diplomatic language can repair that.